Stanford Tops 2013 List Of America’s Best Business Schools
The M.B.A. graduating class of 2008 entered the job market in the teeth of the Great Recession. It was slim pickings for jobs for those outside the elite programs. Even grads of top schools got whacked. “My post-MBA career started with a nightmare, as I joined Lehman Brothers and the bank imploded within three weeks,” says Petr Ostapenko who earned a degree from the University of Chicago’s Booth School of Business. He ended up on the street and Lehman reclaimed his signing bonus. Ostapenko eventually landed a job at Russian oil giant Lukoil, and says, “I got pushed back a few years in my career development, but I still don’t regret my MBA for a second.”
The flame-out of leading banks like Lehman and Bear Sterns, as well as reduced hiring at remaining banking stalwarts like Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, has taken some of the shine off the M.B.A. in recent years. Fewer investment bankers have contributed to lower overall salaries for recent grads at top schools and a slower payback on their M.B.A. Despite the turmoil, most grads at elite schools, like Ostapenko, are still satisfied with their decision to a make a massive investment that can reach nearly $300,000, on average, in tuition and foregone salary at a school like Booth.
We rank full-time M.B.A programs every two years based on return on investment. This year we found the degree still pays off at our top 25 U.S. programs—just not as fast. The average payback period for the Class of 2008 was 3.7 years versus 2.7 years a decade ago. Salaries five years out of school were down from two years ago for all but two schools in the top 10 with only Stanford’s Graduate School of Business and Michigan’s Ross School of Business bucking the trend.
Stanford is the best business school in the U.S., by our count, when it comes to return on investment. It moves up from No. 2 in our previous study (it ranked No. 1 in 2009). Stanford grads tied for the highest paychecks entering school at $80,000, but they scorched the competition with the biggest salaries five years out of school. Their median total compensation of $221,000 was up from $205,000 two years ago for five years out grads.
Stanford is the most selective school in the country, accepting only 7% of applicants for the Class of 2014. Graduates are among the most sought after by employers and they often have the pick of the litter on jobs. The school acts a feeder program to coveted employment spots like consultancies Bain, Boston Consulting Group and McKinsey, as well as tech giants Apple and Google. These were the top five destinations for grads last year and they all land among the top six most desirable employment locations for M.B.A.s in an annual survey compiled by Universum.
Our eighth biennial ranking of business schools is based on the return on investment achieved by the graduates from the class of 2008. We surveyed 17,000 alumni from 100 schools and heard back from 27% of those grads. We compared their earnings in their first five years out of business school to their opportunity cost (two years of forgone compensation, tuition and required fees) to arrive at a “5-year M.B.A. Gain.” Stanford’s median 5-year gain was $99,700 (click here for detailed methodology).
Booth ranks No. 2, up from third last year, with a 5-year M.B.A. gain of $92,600. The 549 members of the Class of 2008 were earning $76,000 on average before they arrived at school and $200,000 five years out. Lehman was the second biggest employer for the class with 23 hires, but many were able to transition to Barclays and Nomura, which bought Lehman divisions after its bankruptcy filing. Other top employers included McKinsey, Bain, Merrill Lynch and BCG. Booth grads got a boost on their M.B.A gains because of the lower cost of living in the Midwest—where around 30% of Chicago grads end up each year—versus elite schools in the East where grads gravitate to pricey Boston and New York (we adjust the salaries for the cost of living when calculating the 5-year gains).
Harvard Business School falls to No. 3 after ranking first in 2011. Harvard, Stanford and fourth-ranked University of Pennsylvania Wharton School of Business all had median salaries of $80,000 for the entering classes. But Harvard’s five-years out total comp fell 11% from $230,000 two years to $205,000 in this year’s study. The result was a 5-year M.B.A. gain of $79,600 versus $118,000 in 2011.
In addition to slower payback periods, we’ve seen reduced 5-year gains over the past decade. The average 5-year gain for grads at the top 25 schools was $118,000 a decade ago, but only $68,000 this year. Five-year out salaries averaged $159,000 this year, but that represents an annual gain of only 1.8% since 2003, which was slower than the rate of inflation.
An increasing number of students are finding it hard to make the degree pay off, particularly when they are saddled with debt levels that can top $100,000 at graduation (the typical alum from the Class of 2008 had $65,000 in debt). One New York University Stern School grad put it candidly: “Business school is a waste of time and money. If you want to blow $100k, go to Vegas.”
American schools produced more than 126,000 M.B.A.s in 2011, up 74% from a decade earlier, according to the Department of Education. There aren’t enough good jobs to satisfy everyone. Investment banks used to hire hundreds of grads each year during the 1990s and figure out what to do with them later. Those days are over and they are not coming back any time soon.
One company that has filled some of the hiring gap left by banks is Amazon.com, which didn’t even exist as a company 20 years ago. It was among the top five hiring firms for 22 of the schools we surveyed (they were cited by only two schools five years ago). The $67 billion-in-sales Internet retailer hired has tripled in size since 2009 and the growth has brought increased hiring of b-school grads.
Amazon typically hires hundreds of M.B.A.s each year. Twenty grads alone from MIT’s Sloan School of Management landed jobs last year, as did 14 from Michigan’s Ross School of Business. Many of the new hires came through the company’s internship program. “We’ve been thrilled with the quality of M.B.A. students and graduates we’ve hired, and we’re excited to continue growing this important channel of leadership talent,” says a company spokesman
Consulting firms are still hiring grads from top schools at rapid rates and hefty salaries. Bain, BCG, Deloitte and McKinsey hire hundreds of grads apiece each year. McKinsey hired 108 from Insead alone in 2012. We heard back from nearly 1,000 Class of 2008 grads that went into consulting and their median first-year total compensation was $142,000. It was $169,000 for Insead consulting grads.
The biggest gainer of schools in the top 10 was Duke University’s Fuqua School of Business, which moved up four spots to No. 8. Fuqua grads from the Class of 2008 earned $63,000 before arriving at school and $152,000 most recently. Five-year out salaries at Fuqua are down from two years ago, as they are at most schools, but Duke bumped its average financial aid package nearly 40%, which helped boost its ROI relative to other U.S. schools.
Dropping out of the top 10 for the first time since 2001 is Virginia’s Darden School of Business. They rank No. 15 this year, down from ninth in 2011, as five-year out salaries fell 11% to $158,000. ROI was also hit by a 15% increase in tuitions and reduced financial aid, compared to the Class of 2006.